Everything Before the Comeback · 2010–2019

The Origin Years

A group of high-school kids started a fantasy league in 2010 and never stopped. Ten years of it before Nima's comeback: a boom to twelve teams, a revolving cast of friends, a last-place scandal that got a grown man banned, and three straight years of championship football so bad it needs an asterisk. All of it pulled straight from Yahoo and checked manager by manager.

How this started

A high-school group chat that refused to grow up

The OJT started in 2010, back when most of these guys were still in high school. They graduated in 2015 and kept playing. They've got jobs now, rent, actual responsibilities, and they still torch every fall arguing over kicker streams like their lives depend on it. Eight bored teenagers picking fantasy teams turned into sixteen years of the same crew refusing to let the thing die. That's the cool part. Now the ugly part.

It did not start pretty. The rosters were a revolving door of friends who got dragged in, beaten senseless, and never seen again. Pige has been here since the very first season in 2010, and by 2013 he was leading the whole league in scoring. Jimmy went 10–3 right next to him and neither could reach a final. Jack won a title on two roster moves. Kirby, the league's forever punching bag, actually won the whole thing in 2013. The crew came together fast, and one thing held the entire time. The best team kept losing. The talent was getting robbed before there was even a trophy worth stealing. The receipts are below. So are the bodies.

8→12→10
Teams, and the chaos between
It opened as an 8-team league in 2010, swelled to a bloated twelve in 2014, then settled at ten. Managers came and went the whole way.
2013
The year the band showed up
Only four of today's ten were in it for 2010 and 2012. By 2013, eight of them were in. The whole league basically formed in one season.
6–7
Three straight titles, three losing records
Brandon, then Pige, then Jack, from 2017 to 2019, every champion under .500. Three years running, the best team in the league got mugged. The trophy has never meant less.
9
Champions, all still here
Every crown from 2010 to 2019 belongs to a current member, Millan, Jack (×3), Kirby, Pige (×2), Shane, Brandon. The rotating cast of friends never won a thing.

How the league formed

It didn't fill up all at once. For years it was a couple of today's regulars mixed with a rotating cast of friends who have long since vanished.

In 2010, four of today's managers were already in: Nima, Millan, Shane and Pige. 2012 had four again: Nima, Millan, Jack and Pige. Then 2013 happened, and the roster jumped to eight at once, adding Kirby, Jimmy and Austin with Shane back in. Austin was a 2013 original who bailed and came back in 2018. Brandon joined in 2014, Miles in 2016. The full ten weren't in one room until Nima's 2020 return. Everyone else on these tables, the Christophers and Kyles and Nicks, are friends who got bored and left. None of them ever won.

20104 of 10
20124 of 10
20138 of 10 · the band shows up
20148 of 10
20158 of 10
20169 of 10 · +Miles
20178 of 10 · Nima banned
20189 of 10 · Austin's back
20199 of 10
202010 of 10

Today's ten managers, by how many were in the league each year. It jumped from four to eight in 2013 and basically stuck. Austin ducked out for a few years, Nima was serving his ban, and the full ten weren't in one room until 2020.

Champions of the era

Nine titles in ten years, 2011 was a lockout. Every winner is still in the league today. But keep an eye on the last three, all won with a losing record: 6–7, 6–7, 6–7.

2010
Millan
11–2 · most points
wire to wire
2011
lockout
no season
2012
Jack
7–6 · 2 moves
laziest title
2013
Kirby
8–5
two 10–3s went home
2014
Pige
8–5
12-team year
2015
Shane
9–4
first of two
2016
Jack
9–4
ring #2
2017
Brandon
6–7
mickey-mouse
2018
Pige
6–7
mickey-mouse
2019
Jack
6–7
mickey-mouse

Jack's 2012 title is the laziest in league history: 7–6 on two roster moves all season. Kirby won 2013 at 8–5 while two 10–3 teams (Pige and Jimmy) went home. And 2010 stands alone as the one year the best team actually finished the job, Millan went 11–2 with the most points and took it.

The Suspension

Every league has one story it doesn't bring up at the reunion. Here's that story.

The crime

Banned three years for the sin of being bad

In 2016 the league invented its first-ever last-place punishment and immediately handed it to Nima, who'd just gone a repulsive 2–11. The sentence: post a bikini pic of himself on social media. So he appealed, and he was right, for the record. The guy he was racing for last had padded his wins against teams that didn't even set their lineups: no kicker in, half their studs on a bye. It wasn't football, it was a bye-week bake sale. He wasn't bad, the season was rigged. The league heard every word of it, nodded, and banned his ass for three years.

The vindication

Then the league spent three years proving him right

With Nima gone, the OJT cranked out three straight champions with losing records. 6–7. 6–7. 6–7. Shane went 10–3 twice and won jack shit. Every single year the best team got its lunch money taken by some 6–7 scrub holding a trophy. Three full seasons of hard evidence that the league he got banned for calling a clown show was, in fact, a clown show. The comeback is a different page. This one belongs to Brandon, Pige and Jack, and the losing records they lifted the trophy with.

The argument, before it had a name

The most-points prize didn't exist yet. These are the years that made everyone realize it had to.

2010

The one time the system worked. Millan went 11–2 with the most points and actually won. Frame it, it doesn't happen again for years.

2012

Nima went 11–2, scored the most points in the league, and didn't even make the final. Jack took the title at 7–6 on two roster moves. The entire wins-vs-points fight, born in one season.

2013

Two teams went 10–3, Pige (most points) and Jimmy. Neither reached the final. Kirby won at 8–5.

2014

Millan led the league in points at 9–4 and didn't even medal. Nima went 10–3 and grabbed a bronze. Pige won it at 8–5. Twelve teams, one lesson.

2015

Pige put up the most points in the league, 1,586, at 9–4 and lost the final. Shane took the ring.

2016

Jimmy had the best team on the board, 10–3 with the most points, and won nothing. Jack won at 9–4. Same movie, fifth showing.

Six seasons, and five times the team that led in points or record didn't win. Jimmy and Pige were "best team, no ring" a decade before anyone built a spreadsheet about it. The prize came later. The pain was always there.

Standings, year by year

Every pre-2020 season, ranked by regular-season record with the playoff medals laid on top, plus points for, points against and the transaction count. Current members are in bold; the faded names are the departed cast (a dash means a locked private profile). Tap a year to open it.

Champion Runner-up Third Medals are the playoff finish. Rows rank by regular-season record, points for breaks ties. A team can sit at the top and win nothing, or wear gold from the middle of the table.

2010 · Millan, wire to wire 8 teams · Nima's very first season
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Millan Millan Eats World11–21390110312
2ld the i.t. crowd10–31308104823
3Pige Black Sheep8–5120811131
4hardcore parcour6–71170113815
5ShaneThe Romosexuals6–7945105816
6ChadLostHisJohnson5–8115311552
7NimaThe Awesome Nima's4–91182125510
8Foozy Nuesbaums2–1175112370

The one origin year the system worked: Millan went 11–2 with the most points and took the whole thing wire to wire. Even here the bracket got weird: a 10–3 team ("the i.t. crowd") settled for third while Pige grabbed runner-up at 8–5, in the league's very first season. Eight teams, everyone made the playoffs, and "Foozy Nuesbaums" still found a way to go 2–11 with a 750 for.

2012 · Jack's 2-move title 8 teams · the argument is born
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1NimaShark Face Gang11–2150512596
2Average Joes7–61399136819
3Jack Frigid Aardvark Cum7–6134512962
4Goats7–6119111600
5ChristopherThe IT Crowd6–71313132412
6PigeJake and Amir6–7110512470
7Suck my Vick5–81359134912
8MillanSherpa for Life3–10121014247

The argument that never dies was born right here. The best team on the board went 11–2 with the most points in the league and won nothing. Jack took the title from the middle of the pack at 7–6 on two roster moves all year, the laziest ring in league history. Only four of today's ten were even in it yet.

2013 · the league forms 10 teams · 8 of today's 10 arrive
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Pige Alex Pehrson's Team10–31566134420
2Jimmytheugliestpetrakes10–31413115226
3Kirby Kirby's Team8–51401128014
4JasonPlanet Z8–51365124516
5Shane Emma Brummond7–61383140924
6NimaDr Drain's Dynasty6–71341133931
7MillanSherpa Life6–71270128514
8JackLopeísisté teamísisé5–8121813739
9AustinAustin's Team3–101218132113
10ChristopherChristopher2–111080150812

The season the OJT basically formed: eight of today's ten are on this board. Pige put up a monster, 10–3 with the most points in the league (1566), and it bought him nothing but a bronze. Jimmy went 10–3 too and got zero, and his team "theugliestpetrakes" was a roast of Jack, who was running "Lopeísisté teamísisé" down in 8th. Kirby won it all from third at 8–5. Two 10–3 teams, no ring between them. Sound familiar?

2014 · the 12-team peak 12 teams · Pige takes it
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1We dem buns10–31426125723
2Nima Tappa Zukie's Team10–31400115340
3MillanSensei Holmes9–41456123614
4Pige Yung's Team8–51344121133
5KirbyCalvin and Cobb7–61271125516
6Jack Turn Down for Watt7–61244127621
7ChristopherChristopher's Team6–71274125122
8KylePeety Pablo6–71069135932
9BrandonWinning Is My Forte5–81248129715
10ShaneMoney Team5–81140131023
11JimmyEifert tower4–91234134125
12$ Zack's B Cups $1–12106712282

The bloated twelve-team high-water mark. Millan led the entire league in scoring at 9–4 and didn't sniff a medal. Two 10–3 teams, "We dem buns" and "Tappa Zukie's Team," split one bronze between them. Pige won it all from fourth at 8–5. Footnote for the archives: that "Tappa Zukie" name up at #2 is the exact one that would win the 2025 title, eleven years later. "$ Zack's B Cups $" mailed in a 1–12 on two moves.

2015 · Shane's first ring 10 teams · Pige scores the most, loses
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Pige SremmLife9–41586134519
2Shane The White Knight9–41403126932
3Jimmy dimsdale degenerates8–51346124729
4MillanSicarios8–51326124429
5KyleMcCoy8–51273135616
6KirbyMy ball Zach Ertz6–71258123522
7JackKira Laurento(sloth)5–81339129018
8BrandonJohn Stamos5–8114713105
9NickNick's Nice Team4–9110312840
10NimaNick's Naughty Team3–101144134534

Shane's first ring, won from second. Pige topped the whole league in points at 1586 on a 9–4 record and lost the final, the points-without-a-ring identity he still carries a decade later. Down at the bottom, Nima cratered to 3–10 and dead last, the slide toward his ban already underway.

2016 · Jack again, Miles debuts 10 teams · Nima's last before the ban
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1JimmyOJTs BEST athlete10–3147013768
2Jack Kira Laurento(sloth)9–41333130613
3Miles Kira Fatrento7–61429129410
4KyleMcCoy7–61369134817
5KirbyKirbys team7–61275126939
6MillanKira Lacameltoe6–71392129730
7BrandonJohn Stamos6–71242138015
8Pige SremmLife 26–71180120949
9ShaneClits Out 4 Harambe5–81270136715
10NimaA-Dawgs Siceingteam2–111312142739

Jack's second ring, taken from second at 9–4. Jimmy sat on top of the standings at 10–3 with the most points in the league and walked away with nothing, the pattern that still defines him. Pige backed into a runner-up from 6–7. Rookie Miles snagged bronze. And at the very bottom, Nima's 2–11 was his worst season ever, and the last one before a three-year ban.

2017 · the first clown title 10 teams · Nima banned · champ went 6–7
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Shane The GB Packers10–31340112536
2JackWilliam Football III9–41242123610
3KirbyKirbys team8–51382128840
4PigeLUV Is Rage 27–61348125022
5MillanChat $hIt Get Banged7–61196114634
6Brandon John Stamos6–7121112717
7Jimmy OJTs BEST athlete5–81169135911
8MilesPlayboiCartiIsMyDad5–8111011338
9KyleMcCoy4–91188126813
10NickLil JuiceBox4–91177128732

The first title of the ban set the tone perfectly. Shane owned the regular season at 10–3 and lost the final to a 6–7 team, so Brandon lifted the trophy from sixth place in the standings. A 5–8 Jimmy somehow snagged the bronze. Almost the whole crew was already here, missing only Nima and Austin, with Kyle and Nick the last two randoms parked at the bottom where they belonged.

2018 · Pige wins with a losing record 10 teams · 6–7 champ, most points against
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Shane Boca Box Munchers10–31572134237
2Jack William Football III8–51422128213
3BrandonJohn Stamos8–51413141817
4Pige Eternal Atake6–71484153516
5JimmyOJTs BEST athlete6–71474149321
6KirbyKirbys team6–71423141532
7MilesTriptheKid6–7129114101
8KyleWavìPapï5–8138514638
9MillanChat $hIt Get Banged5–81275129531
10AustinAustin's Team5–8125013368

Pige won the whole thing at 6–7, a losing record, from fourth in the standings. His opponents dropped more points on him than anyone in the league all year, the worst luck on the board, and he won anyway. Meanwhile Shane went 10–3, led the league in points, and settled for bronze. Robbed again. The man could not buy a ring in this era.

2019 · Jack, 6–7, from the 7-seed 10 teams · the last title before Nima came back
RkManagerTeamRecPFPAMv
1Pige Eternal Atake9–41531126831
2MillanChickenTikka MoSalah9–41422118730
3KyleWavìPapï8–51459142219
4KirbyKirbys team8–51317137931
5JimmyOJTs BEST athlete7–61332128119
6Shane Boca Box Munchers6–71353127229
7Jack William Football III6–71321122524
8BrandonJohn Stamos5–81239135420
9AustinJewish Messiah4–91174133911
10MilesTriptheKid3–10105914836

The last clown title before the ban lifted: Jack won it all at 6–7 as the 7-seed, buried seventh in the standings. Two 9–4 teams sat on top, and Millan's reward for the second-best record was an early playoff exit. Shane snuck onto the podium again, bronze from a 6–7 record. Miles finished dead last at 3–10, a rookie gag for a guy on year four. Then the ban lifted, the league rewrote its whole constitution, and recess was over.

Hall of Fame & Shame · origin cut

A decade is plenty of time to earn a plaque. Or a restraining order.

The Two-Move Trophy
Jack, 2012

Won a championship on two roster moves the entire season. Didn't lift a finger, still lifted the trophy. Living proof you can win this league in a coma.

Best Team, No Luck
Pige, 2010–19

Runner-up in the league's very first season, then the most points in the league by 2013 with nothing to show for it. He has been the best roster that can't finish since day one. Started early, never stopped.

The Eleven-Year Setup
Nima, 2014

Named a team "Tappa Zukie," went 10–3, choked. Then dusted off the exact same name in 2025 and won the whole thing. An eleven-year troll nobody saw coming.

The 750 Club
Foozy Nuesbaums, 2010

Went 2–11 and put up 750 points across an entire season, in an eight-team league, then vanished off the face of the earth. One of the worst rosters ever assembled. He knew, and he bounced.

Effort Not Found
$ Zack's B Cups $, 2014

Went 1–12 in the twelve-team season on a grand total of two moves. Quit in September and rode it straight to the basement. Didn't even give the league the courtesy of trying.

Robbery, Broad Daylight
Shane, 2017–18

Went 10–3 in back-to-back seasons with the best team in the league both years and walked off with a silver and a bronze. Mugged twice by 6–7 champions. The most robbed man of the entire era, and it is not close.

← Back to the record book (2020–2025)